In the beginning of the article the author poses the idea
that the multisport athlete is dying. “The multi-sport high school
athlete is gone; we all know this. It’s a thing of the past, like black and
white TV. It’s the era of specialization, of kids “focusing” on one sport, often
because they (or their parents) are chasing (often unrealistically) a
scholarship, or because coaches have made it too difficult to do other sports.”
I talk to
athletes all the time about the amount of pressure coming from coaches to have
the athletes commit to playing one sport. It feels like the athletes have to
choose at a younger age. Ericsson’s idea of the 10000 hours was a catalyst for
parents and coaches to begin to specialize. My question is why can’t an athlete
specialize in one sport but still play multi-sports? First let’s define
specialization so we have a basis to look. “Sport specialization is defined as
students limiting participation to one sport which is practiced, trained for,
and/or competed in on a year-round basis” (Hill, 1991, p. 186)
Secondly, I
decided to find the answer through a quick questionnaire of the women players
in our top volleyball league in Canada, in the Canadian Interuniversity Sports
(CIS).. For the purpose of this blog we will assume that these athletes are a
good cross section of our top volleyball players in the country. For those
readers outside of Canada, the CIS is our equivalent to Division 1 university
volleyball. We will assume that they are a good cross section of our top
volleyball players in the country.
I sent the
questionnaire out to the 38 teams in the CIS that offer scholarships in
volleyball. I sent the email directly to their head coaches to see if they
could help me. At this point in the process I have received email and
statistics back from 12 of the institutions. That is a total of 180 athletes. The
distribution of the teams that replied was a good cross-section of the whole
country. This is the breakdown of the replying teams from the questionnaires; 5
of the teams participate in the Canada West Division, 3 of the teams were from
the Ontario division, 2 from the Quebec division and 2 from the Atlantic
conference.
I asked the head coaches of the programs to
answer these three questions.
1.
How many players on your team played more than 1 sport in their last two
years of high school?
2.
What were the sports?
3.
How many played club volleyball?
I was very
surprised by the result.
We found that 83%
of the athletes played more than one sport in high school. This is also while 97%
of the athletes played club volleyball
The following
chart is a breakdown of the different sports the athletes played.
SPORT
|
PARTICIPANTS
|
PERCENTAGE OF ATHLETES PLAYING THE
SPORT
|
Basketball
|
75
|
41.32%
|
Soccer
|
58
|
32.22
|
Track
|
41
|
22.77
|
Softball
|
25
|
13.88
|
Badminton
|
22
|
12.22
|
Ringette/Hockey
|
12
|
6.66
|
Beach Vball
|
15
|
8.33
|
Swimming
|
14
|
7.77
|
Lacrosse
|
6
|
3.33
|
Rugby
|
6
|
3.33
|
Ski/Snowbarding
|
8
|
4.44
|
Tennis
|
5
|
2.77
|
Ultimate Frisbee
|
4
|
2.22
|
Figure Skating
|
3
|
1.66
|
Cross Country
|
2
|
1.11
|
Water
Polo
|
1
|
0.05
|
Field
Hockey
|
1
|
0.05
|
Flag
Football
|
1
|
0.05
|
Sailing
|
1
|
0.05
|
Gymnastics
|
3
|
1.66
|
Golf
|
1
|
0.05
|
Dance
|
1
|
0.05
|
Trampoline
|
1
|
0.05
|
Martial
Arts
|
3
|
1.66
|
With looking at the high percentage of athletes that play
club volleyball it is simple to say that if you want to play high level
university volleyball you must play club volleyball. I would believe that this would be a common
thought out in the Canadian volleyball community.
The second point I derive from this is that it is still very
important to sample other sports in your high school career. In discussion with
my athletes at Brandon University, most felt they made the decision to play
volleyball at the elite level.
Volleyball was going to be their primary sport. They said that they
identified themselves more as a volleyball player than any other sport. They chose to play the other sports for a
mental break from volleyball, for companionship with other friends who they
have been playing with for years, and also because they enjoyed the other
sports.
Using the previous definition we quoted from Hill the
athletes from Brandon University specialized in volleyball. Most of them played high school volleyball from
September to November, then they moved onto club volleyball December to May,
and finally provincial team in July.
They often overlapped their season of play so they could participate in
the other sports. The athletes stated
they took their secondary sports seriously; they practiced hard and set high
goals in those sports as well. It was
another chance to compete.
As a university coach, when out recruiting, I ask what other sports they play as
well. I find that multisport athletes
are able to pick up new movement patterns faster than single sport athletes, but
I have no true data to prove this other than years of observation. Multisport athletes have a strong grasp of
the creation of space and the understanding of locating trends of
oppositions. They also tend to have more
of a growth mindset as they try to become strong in multiple sports.
I believe that athletes in high school should be allowed to
sample other sports during their school years, but their main focus needs to be
on the sport that they want to excel in.